Rameez Nooruddin

notes, sidenotes, footnotes and what-nots.

Windows Phone 7 Metro UI breaks spatiality

"Wow!"

That was the impression I had when I watched the video. I love the Metro UI in Windows Phone 7. It is fantastic. It flips the Apple's idea of a phone UI — of applications being silos with limited interactions between them — by letting data and actions take centre-stage.

However, Metro breaks spatiality. After a series of seemingly endless list of menus (and once that seem to fall off the screen), it is a little disorienting. Some questions regarding the UI:

  • You could lose track of where you are and what screen the Back button might take you to.
  • Now what if you accidentally hit the Home button? Will you be able to recollect the series of menu options you had taken to reach the previous position?
  • Put simply: isn't the practice of allowing multiple ways of doing the same thing, each through a different set of menu selections, a little too confusing for an average user? Especially on a phone.
  • How do I read the full title of the document?